New entry on my blog roll – Why should people have to justify the right to own their own body?

Dammit Janet left the progressive bloggers blogroll thing because the folk there decided to reopen the “debate” over abortion.

On the face of it what is wrong with a debate? Everyone loves to talk things through and arrive at a decision that takes into account all the facts, don’t they? In a debate yes, but this isn’t a debate at all. It is a “debate” or rather a backhanded way of telling a segment of society that their rights are dependent on the charity of others, not like the rights of other segments of society.

Me as a white guy, living in the West I have a pretty privileged life and a whole swack of rights, one of which is the right to decide what I do with my body and that others cannot do anything to it without my permission. Those insisting that there is something to “debate”about abortion are saying that women don’t have that right. They are not as entitled to the same rights of citizenship that I am. They are saying that just by proposing that there is even a “debate” on the issue.

Straight away the alarm bells are ringing.

Imagine if in the same fora someone was to say, “yep about that whole equality of the races under the law thing, are you sure that’s a good idea? Shouldn’t we “debate” that some more?” or, “why should people who don’t own land have a vote? They have no material stake in the country. Let’s “debate” on that.”

I think I know how folk would respond to those suggestions and quite rightly too. But I’ve noticed that women’s and homosexual’s rights are very frequently up for “debate,” immigrants and non-whites rights next most frequently and white men’s rights, well … pretty much never.

I wonder why that is? Isn’t it just a “debate” after all? And what’s wrong with “debate?”

h/t TGB for the idea of “debate”

About harebell

Live in Alberta Fiscally conservative and socially more "live and let live" though I draw the line at folk who abuse their authority. Never bored
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to New entry on my blog roll – Why should people have to justify the right to own their own body?

  1. CanNurse says:

    Yes! Fantastic analogy re racial equality, civil rights, etc. Thank you!

  2. fern hill says:

    Thanks. We will reciprocate.

    Good to find more allies in the upcoming totally unnecessary ‘debate’. Abortion Rights Coalition of Canada has a Motion 312 Action Kit with sample letter, MP finder, and link to a petition that’s coming up to 8700 signatures. Please sign and forward.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s